IBM New “low cost” desktop
Thought this was intresting. If IBM wants people to use their PowerPC chips on the desktop then need to go a lot lower than $4,000 for a “desktop” workstation. I can get an entry level Sun Blade 150 machine for under $1,000. Granted it does not have the same specs as the IBM one does, but for some one starting out on a platform, I would much rather spend less money and get a slightly slower machine than a lot to find out that something does not work right. One thing that is not mentioned on that page, but on the IBM page is that it is really a “server”. Which means this little desktop machine weighs in a 55 pounds. Now to compare this machine versus a Sun Ultra 45, just on specs from each vendors web site lets see both maxed out:
| System Option | Sun Ultra45 | IBM pSeries 185 Express | Advantage |
| Memory (Max) | 16GB | 8GB | Ultra45 |
| Processor Speed | 2 x 1.6GHz UltraIIIi | 2 x 2.5GHZ PPC 970 (not the real G5′s) | Ultra45 |
| L2 Cache | 1MB/Processor | 1MB/Processor | Tie |
| Network | Dual Onboard Gig | Dual Onboard Gig | Tie |
| USB | 6 USB 2.0 | 4 USB (does not mention whether 2.0 or not) | Ultra45 |
| Disk Drives | 4 x 146GB 15K SAS | 3 x Ultra320 SCSI | Ultra45 |
| Optical | DVDRW/CDRW | DVD-ROM or DVDRAM | Ultra45 |
| Weight | 58 Pounds Fully loaded | 55 Pounds empty | Ultra45 |
| OS | Solaris 10, Free | AIX 5.3, $300 | Ultra45 |
| OS Support | 3 Years, $648 | 3 Years, $1,614 | Ultra 45 |
| Hardware Warrenty (default) | 90 days | 3 Years | pSeries 185 |
All in all, you may end up paying a little more for a Ultra45, but then again, it is a way better machine than the pSeries 185. It also runs Solaris which I feel is far superior to AIX. AIX is cool and all, but has too many quirks that just does not make to much sense. There are things in Solaris that are done so much easier and faster than in AIX that just make me laugh when I have to answer how to do something in AIX vs Solaris.
Here are some of my pet quirks about AIX:
- Disk numbering scheme: all disks in AIX are named in the form of hdisk#. To find out exactly where they are at you have to do either a “lsdev -Cc disk” or “lsattr -El hdisk#” to find the actual controller and slot it is connected to.
- ODM: Seems too much like the windows registry to me. Screw it up, and your machine does not boot right
- The “dumbing” of Sysadmins by their dependence on SMIT. Take a AIX admin and put them in front of Solaris/Linux/etc and have them try to do any administrative tasks, and it is a complete loss with out smit. But take a Solaris/Linux/etc admin and put them on AIX, and they can accomplish most of the same administrative tasks with out touching SMIT
- NIM, Nim is AIX’s equivelant of Jumpstart on Solaris. Jumpstart can be setup in probably under 10 minutes and be booting and installing machines. Nim on the other hand is an all day affair. I kid you not, I spent 8+ hours one day configuring an NIM environment to boot 1 machine. And even then, it did not install all the needed software. It also takes forever to copy 8 CD’s of AIX install media, plus the “Linux ToolKit”, Plus the expansion pack just to get SSH installed on AIX when NIM is used to install a system. If I could only get AIX to boot from a jumpstart server I would be set.
- Missing core software that should be installed no matter what type of install you do. For example SSH. What operating system besides Microsoft Windows now days does not come installed with SSH? AIX, yup, you have to have 3 different cd’s to install it, and you better be using the OpenSSH supplied by IBM, or they will refuse to talk to you about any problems. (Yes they actually had me verify every part of the version of SSH before they would talk to me.
- Root allowed to log in remotely. By default when you install AIX, root can log in remotely. MMM Bad Mkay…..
- Default Open Relay: Last time I checked Sendmail on AIX is still configured by default to be an open relay.
- Syslog: AIX likes to put stuff in its proprietory errpt. Which means to get the information to log to a central syslog server, you have to modify the ODM to run a script to grab output from the errpt command to send to syslog. Why can’t it send to syslog by default?
And the list could go on for ever, but right now it is time to go to bed.
AIX, Computer Hardware, IBM, Random Stuff, Rant, Solaris, Sun
